Open Banking and Financial Fraud: What Happens When Money Moves Across Multiple Accounts?
Open banking lets a customer approve a payment from one bank account to another through an application programming interface (API), and the question that follows most scams is where the money goes after the first receiving account forwards it. The answer decides how much a bank can trace, which institutions hold evidence of each transfer, and whether anyone can name the person behind the final account.
Two 2026 publications now cover both halves of that question. Open Banking Limited (OBL), which oversees the UK framework, released its first Open Banking Payments & Fraud Monitor in July 2026, and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) published a review of money mule activity on 23 September 2026. This article therefore covers (i) how much fraud open banking payments carry, (ii) where stolen money goes next, (iii) the warning signs, (iv) the rules in the UK, the European Union (EU) and the United States, (v) the public record checks that fit the case, and (vi) what a fraud team should do first.
How much fraud do open banking payments carry?
Open banking is a framework in which a customer gives a regulated third party permission, through open banking APIs, to read account data or to start a payment between bank accounts. The fraud figures below concern the payments.
OBL reports that open banking fraud stays below wider industry benchmarks, at 0.024% of payments in the first quarter of 2026. Authorised push payment (APP) fraud, where the payer approves the transfer after a criminal has manipulated them, makes up more than two thirds of cases, and investment fraud is among the largest APP categories by value. Retail Banker International notes that once a customer approves a payment, many of a bank’s strongest controls are no longer designed to intervene, so a low rate and continuing losses occur together.
What happens to stolen money after the first account?
The FCA review found that fraud proceeds, including those that start with an open banking payment, are usually cashed out after passing through two to five mule accounts, most often at the second. Frontier Economics, in its July 2026 evaluation of APP scam policies, defines a mule as a person or account used to receive, move or transfer funds obtained through fraud, and a second generation mule as an account that receives funds from another mule instead of from the victim.
Each hop can sit at a different institution, and by the time the money is cashed out it has been split into smaller payments, which makes it harder to trace. The open banking payment record covers the first transfer. Every later hop appears only in the records of the institution that holds that account.
Who holds the accounts in a money mule chain?
Personal accounts made up about 92% of suspected mule account closures reported to the FCA between 2023 and 2025, so most mule activity behind open banking fraud runs through personal accounts. Some holders know what they are doing and others do not: the Home Office research Lived Experiences of Money Muling, published in July 2026, interviewed nine mules, all unwitting, who had been recruited through job advertisements, social media or people they knew.
The FCA also found accounts reused across several fraud types, which it reads as a sign of organised criminal infrastructure. Closing one account therefore removes a single hop and leaves the rest of the chain in place, so investigators follow the whole sequence of accounts and not a single one.
Also Read – The Growing Role of Beneficial Ownership Intelligence in 2026
What are the warning signs of fraud across multiple accounts?
None of these signals proves open banking fraud alone, and two or three together justify escalating a case.
| Signal | Published basis | Visible to |
|---|---|---|
| Payer approves a transfer after online contact | UK Finance: 66% of APP cases began online | Payer’s bank |
| Funds pass through a second to fifth account | FCA: usual cash out range | Each holding institution |
| Large sums split into smaller payments | FCA: seen before cash out | Each account’s history |
| Same account appears in several fraud cases | FCA: sign of organised infrastructure | Holding institution |
| Card spending used to move funds | FCA: can resemble normal spending | Card issuer |
| Final beneficiary or linked party returns a sanctions list match | Found outside the payment data | Public record datasets |
How do open banking fraud rules differ between the UK, EU and US?
Who bears the loss from an open banking payment depends on the region. The entries reflect sources reviewed in November 2026.
| Region | Status in 2026 | Effect on fraud losses |
|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom | Mandatory APP reimbursement since 7 October 2024 for Faster Payments and CHAPS | Up to £85,000 per claim, paid by the sending firm within five business days; the receiving firm repays half |
| European Union | Third Payment Services Directive and Payment Services Regulation agreed, publication in the Official Journal expected at the end of 2026 | Full refund for bank impersonation fraud reported to the police; payee name verification has applied to euro area credit transfers since 9 October 2025 |
| United States | Section 1033 open banking rule enjoined by a federal court, with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) rewriting it | Reconsideration covers fees, data security and privacy |
Also Read – Why does the Bank of America $1.2 billion fine matter for compliance teams?
Where do public record checks fit in an open banking fraud case?
Most mule account holders are ordinary account holders who often appear on no list, so a name check on the mule layer returns little. The checks earn their place at the end of the chain: on the beneficiary who receives the cash out, on business payees, and on counterparties linked to the case. Three datasets serve that purpose.
| Dataset | Coverage | Use in a case |
|---|---|---|
| Global sanctions data | Individuals, companies and organisations under international sanctions, from sources including the United Nations, the EU and the US Office of Foreign Assets Control | Exposure to a listed party |
| Politically exposed persons list | Individuals in prominent public positions or positions of authority | Higher exposure to corruption |
| Warrants and criminal entities data | Outstanding warrants and entities linked to criminal activity, from public national warrant and court records and published INTERPOL Red Notices | Criminal links outside the payment |
Most Red Notices stay restricted to INTERPOL’s law enforcement network, so no commercial dataset confirms them. The datasets cover more than 180 countries and are structured for API access, so the check can run inside a case workflow for one name or many. None of them traces funds. A match is a lead for review, and a clean result means only that the name matched no listed record.
Also Read – Criminal History Check vs Warrants Search: What Sets Them Apart?
What should a fraud team do first when money has already moved?
Two steps come first: (i) record the payment identifier, consent reference, time and amount of the open banking payment, which fix the first hop, and (ii) notify both the sending and the receiving institution, because only the receiving institution sees where the funds went next.
Three steps follow: (iii) list every name, account and payment reference in the case and check the names against sanctions, PEP and warrant records, (iv) order the transfers by time to show which account collected and which forwarded, and (v) for regulated firms, share information under the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023, which the FCA names as a route to detect and investigate economic crime.
A single chain sheet with one row per hop, covering institution, account reference, time received, time sent, amount and record check result, keeps these steps in one document and shows the route the money took in that open banking fraud case.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should an account holder do right after sending money to a fraudster?
Contact the sending bank immediately, because reimbursement claims run through it and the bank can alert the receiving institution. In the UK the claim route is the sending bank, and in the EU a refund for impersonation fraud depends on reporting to the police as well as the provider.
Can money be recovered after an open banking payment goes to a fraudster?
Recovery depends on the country, the payment system and the type of fraud, and the sending bank can confirm whether a specific payment qualifies for reimbursement. The regional table above sets out the UK, EU and US positions.
Why do mule accounts pass a name check on the payee?
Confirmation of Payee in the UK and payee name verification in the EU test whether the name a payer enters matches the name on the receiving account. A mule account carries whatever name it was opened under, so a payer who has been manipulated into entering that name receives a match, and the Payment Systems Regulator reported in 2021 that criminals can use that confidence to steer victims towards mule accounts.
Why can the sending bank not stop funds at a second mule account?
After the first transfer, each later account sits at an institution whose records the sending bank cannot see. The FCA found that closing individual mule accounts does not necessarily disrupt the wider flow of funds, and it points firms to information sharing under the Economic Crime and Corporate Transparency Act 2023.
Who publishes open banking fraud data?
OBL publishes its Open Banking Payments & Fraud Monitor twice a year, with the first edition in July 2026, and UK Finance publishes an annual fraud report, with the 2026 edition released in June 2026.
Are the sanctions, PEP and warrant datasets sold together?
No. Each of the three sanctions, PEP and criminal entity datasets is sold separately, so a team buys the one that matches its exposure.
How often are the datasets refreshed?
Weekly, so newly added, updated and removed records appear in the next refresh.
Can the datasets be tested before purchase?
Yes. The homepage describes three months of free access to the API, with the starter tier set at 3,000 records per month, and requests go through the dataset enquiries page.